Marshmallow

I had high hopes for this marshmallow dip, but it was a huge disappointment in flavor and texture. First of all, when I opened it, it had been shipped on a hot summer day. So I thought the texture was thin and gelatinous like un-set jello because of the heat. Nope. That's just how it is. Even after refrigerating and shaking it vigorously, I would not say "smooth and creamy" describes this. I understand it's a "dip" and isn't supposed to compare to marshmallow fluff, but I was hoping for something in between like a thick sauce I could pour over my homemade keto ice cream. This is a bit too slimy and doesn't move like a dip or a sauce. I could have seen past the texture if the flavor was better. When it comes down to it, marshmallows basically taste like vanilla to me, and how can you possibly get vanilla flavor wrong? Somehow they managed. The intensely sour and bitter flavor doesn't even allow you to taste the sweetness you're expecting from this diet dessert topping. I've tried their chocolate, caramel, strawberry, blueberry, and pancake syrups as well. They all have the same sour and bitter flavor. Such a shame because I had high hopes for this brand that was recommended to me by my dietician. The glass bottle packaging and the nice graphics on the label, highlighting non-gmo and many other fine attributes I like to see in my processed food labels - all of it made me think this was going to be a game-changer that would get me through the halfway point of my weight loss journey. Sadly, I'll have to keep looking. I'd like to try their salad dressings to see if maybe something that's not intended as a dessert flavor will taste better, but all their stuff is so expensive, and at this point I don't want to throw good money after bad.

Does the marshmallow dip have a strange sourness to it? Yeah, admittedly, it does. So, why am I giving five stars? Because it serves the purpose that I bought it for. I got it to make a reduced calorie vanilla protein icing. It's vanilla protein powder, Walden Farms marshmallow dip, and powdered allulose/monkfruit sweetener. Once you mix in other ingredients, the sourness goes away. If you try to do the same and still feel that you taste a bit of sourness, a tiny amount of baking soda will do the trick. And I mean tiny, like 1/8th of a teaspoon. I'm glad that products like this exist to help me cut out empty calories and make room for more nutrient-dense foods in my diet while keeping the weight off.

Eww. I’m really not impressed with this marshmallow dip. I’ve been low-carbing for over five years, so my expectations for sugar-free products are well-informed and realistic. But this is just a little bit gross. It *looks* good. But when you first stick a spoon in it, the texture is more like gelatin than marshmallow cream. It doesn’t coat the spoon; it flops off. The flavor is only slightly sweet, but also a bit sour, and it leaves sort of a burning sensation on your tongue. It’s not quite like a spicy-food burning, though. More like an acidic burn, perhaps? It’s not overwhelming, but it’s there. Imagine taking soft, room-temperature, unflavored gelatin, sweetening it just a bit, adding some white paint, a dash of vinegar, and just a touch of vanilla room freshener, and you’ll get an idea of what to expect with this. Yeah. Eww. Unfortunately, it’s ineligible for return. The product page says you can get a refund or replacement (I definitely don’t want the latter!) if it arrives damaged or defective (and you can’t use the usual process; you’d have to contact customer service). Despite being in glass jars, it arrived undamaged, but does being gross count as “defective”? I suspect not. This is just how they intended it, but it’s certainly not to my liking. I should have known better. I’ve never tried a Walden Farms product that wasn’t gross. If you’ve tried other stuff by them and liked it, this might be to your liking. Otherwise, I’d give it a miss.

Can only dream about getting thick gooey marshmallow crème, but it’s not thick even after refrigerated. It still has a good flavor just real runny.

By far one of the worst products ever. Nasty stuff - very sad I wasted $10.00. Not in any way does this stuff taste like marshmallow. As a dip it is the viscosity of water. I cannot return so I will toss in the trash. Do not buy this product.

Taste is good. It's very runny though. I expected it to be thicker for dipping.

I've been looking for something calorie free to mix with peanut butter for an apple dip. This marshmallow dip is absolutely perfect. By itself, the taste isn't great, although I can taste strong vanilla, which is good. When mixed with peanut butter, it makes a sweet, light, & fluffy dip that I love. I've found that mixing it with equal parts of each makes the nicest spreading and dipping consistency. Marshmallows are made of sugar, so, of course, this can't be exactly the same taste or texture as marshmallow cream, but it certainly works for my purpose! I ordered 1 a couple of weeks ago & am ordering two more today.

I was really worried after looking at other reviews that mine would end up broken, but fortunately it was delivered with care! It got to me early as well, I appreciate the fast shipping. The flavor issssss uhhhhhhhh not amazing. I don't know if I could even recognize is as a marshmallow off the bat. I first tried it with a vegan pumpkin peanut butter cup, trying to create the fluffernutter vibe, but it was not a strong marshmallow flavor. The good thing is that I think there will be easy ways to go through it and it issss 0 calories so that's good. Idk probably not going to buy it again, but glad I took the chance on it regardless.

Non capisco cosa ci trovino nei prodotti di questo marchio, se ne parla sempre tanto tra i guru del fitness. Ok, sono a zero calorie, ma il sapore è qualcosa di tremendo, meglio fare la fame! Avevo provato anche il "peanut spread" dello stesso marchio, anche quello disgustoso! Poi gli ho voluto dare una seconda possibilità con il "marshmallow dip", sperando magari di essere stata sfortunata io l'altra volta...non l'avessi mai fatto! Stesso pessimo retrogusto chimico e anche un po' amarognolo! Meglio sgarrare ogni tanto con delle VERE creme spalmabili, con tutte le loro calorie (che se mangiate saltuariamente e in modica quantità non vi faranno di certo ingrassare, oltre a darvi molta più soddisfazione), che mangiarsi questa cosa tutti i giorni! Mai più questo marchio, statene alla larga!

Extremely gross, runny (like soup) with an unpleasant slimness feeling and the taste is nothing like Marshmellow- extremely chemical tasting.

je m'y attendais mais pas à ce point. Vraiment rein avoir avec le gout marshmallow, j'ai acheté d'autres produit Walden farms et ils étaient assez bon, mais celui-là est vraiment mauvais autant sur le gout que la texture, à éviter, orientez vous plutôt sur les sirops qui sont assez réussis

This tastes absolutely nothing like marshmallow. It is also extremely thin and runny, like water. Don't waste your money!

I don’t think I can put into words just how horrible this stuff is. I rarely throw stuff away, I hate wasting food and money but there is no way that you could refer to this stuff as food, that would imply that it is remotely edible - it’s not. It is a runny chemical tasting goo, nothing like marshmallow in consistency and does not taste anything like marshmallow. You might as well pour some glue in a jar and eat that, it would be cheaper and taste better. I hate that I’ve wasted money on this, it tastes purely of runny chemicals, nothing about it is redeeming. Honestly, this is one of the worst food items I’ve ever bought, and this is coming from someone who has a sugar free diet, it’s not like I’m not use to sugar substitutions. This stuff is just vile!