Milani Tubing Mascara | Highly Rated Mascara - Black | Length and Lift | Shea Butter to Nourish and Condition Lashes

Great product! A buildable mascara that transforms your lashes with each coat and leaves them looking long and lush! The best part though is the fact that this particular mascara is formulated as a tubing mascara! You can literally apply water to your lashes at the end of the day and wipe them clean! If you have a bad day and decide to cry it out, you don't have to worry about running mascara or the typical racoon eyes that other mascara products leave you with! If life gets the best of you, you can just wipe away the tears, and reapply!

I had never even heard of tubing mascara until my 22- and 24-year-old daughters told me about this product and I’m so glad they did. I absolutely love it. It makes my lashes look so good that people ask if I’m wearing fake eyelashes, and I get compliments all the time. What I love most is how easily it comes off with just water, no scrubbing, no soap, and no leftover raccoon eyes. If you haven’t tried tubing mascara yet, don’t wait another second… hit the purchase button.

UPDATE: I started using this over a drier mascara (Tarte ‘gifted’ and Vivienne Sabo ‘cabaret’) and I really like it now, so I added a star. It seems like it works better over another mascara than on bare lashes. I will continue to buy it if it works this well over other mascaras-it’s like a waterproof without the messy removal, and helps keep my lashes curled. But only when I use it in this manner. Lol ORIGINAL POST I really super duper wanted to like this mascara, but it’s been friend-zoned. Lol What I do like: the price, it’s fragrance free, removes easily, and wore all day without agitating my sensitive allergy eyes, flaking or smearing. What I don’t like: it applies super wet. My usual process is I start applying with the brush being vertical, which helps regulate the product, and then apply the second coat as normal. I normally get great results with this technique, but it does not work with this mascara. My lashes are long and fairly thick, I guess, and they were gooped together as if I were applying pan mascara…or vaseline. Lol It was very strange for a tubing mascara; I have tried Blinc to Thrive, and others, and haven’t experienced this before. (Those brands dry up too fast for the price, so I’ve been shopping around.) I tried separating my lashes with a dry spoolie after they dried a bit, but that made it worse. I had to mess around with them for 10 mins before I didn’t have creepy stuck-together doll lashes, and it took forever them to dry. Additionally, it didn’t hold the curl from the lash curler, either. Total bummer for me. On to the next. Sigh.

This is a great tubing mascara with a great price tag. Makes my lashes look full and gives extreme volume qnd length.

I have been struggling with mascara smearing and flaking off during the day and thought I give this one a try. While it is a true tubing mascara, I find that the liquid does not coat my lashes consistently. It is very light at the root and thick and clumpy at the ends. I’m thinking the problem is the applicator. The heavy consistency of the tubing mascara liquid makes it difficult to evenly apply. I used a needle to separate some of the lashes but they still looked clumpy. It did make my lashes look long, it did last all day with no flaking and it didn't smear at all. I would have given it a 5 if it had a better brush and was less clumsy and more feathery as described.

The GOAT as tubing mascaras go. O've tried all kinds of tubing mascaras and this one beats them all. Makes my lashes a mile long with one light coating. The formula is fairly wet so it can smudge when you first apply it, but once dry, I have never had any problem with smudging or flaking. Occasional clumping issues, usually when I've had the tube for a couple of months, but because the formula is wet and takes a minute to dry, if I do get any clumping, I find it's easy to use a comb to separate the lashes again. Pics show me with no mascara, one coat of mascara on one eye, and one coat of mascara on both.

I don't expect a mascara to be perfect for everyone and this was my first tubing mascara. With that said, my natural lashes are very straight and point downward, which is why I need a mascara that can lift and hold a curl. This mascara does neither of those things. I even tried using a primer after I curled my lashes. The only difference is that the primer makes your eyelashes spread out, but still can't hold a curl. While without the primer, this mascara clumps them together. I guess the price is okay and it didn't bother my eyes. It washes off pretty easily but that is not a problem since I use waterproof mascara most of the time. I'll keep sticking with Maybelline Waterproof Skyhigh or Falsies.

Love/hate this mascara. I wanted a mascara that wouldn't smudge or transfer to my brow bone or upper lid. This stuff stays put all day. No smudging or flaking whatsoever. I love it for that. The stuff i hate? Its a very wet and heavy formula. It weighs my lashes down and straightens out any curl. Its also nearly impossible to keep lashes separate. They may look a bit longer, but it also looks like i have fewer lashes than i actually have. Like 18 lashes. I can literally count them. I believe the wand is most of the issue. This mascara would work so much better with a different wand, imo. Its always pretty easy to remove so ill give credit there as well.